Dot or Circle + Dot? Which is Better?
*Some of the external links found on this website are affiliate links. Those links use cookies to generate revenue and fund continuation of this website. By clicking an external link you are consenting to a temporary cookie, by purchasing from that link you are supporting this website. To opt out of cookies do not click external links.

The question between a dot reticle or circle + dot is one I've heard many times. During a range outing it was discovered that Anna prefered a simple dot whereas I have always prefered a circle + dot. We then set out to test if it's a matter of personal preference, situational, or if we really knew what we liked. The results of this test surprised us both.

To test performance fairly without personal bias or skill influencing results we needed more than just one pistol, more than just one optic, and more than one exercise in shooting. Ideally we'd also have different window sizes and ride heights so that the only common experience was reticle.
The Tools

The Canik Phantom was mounted to the TriStar Arms APOC PRO. The RMR-footprint Phantom has a 0.8"x0.69" window and 3moa dot with or without a 32moa circle. The APOC Pro's plate system results in an "optic on gun" ride height.

The Sig Romeo-X Pro came with the Sig P211 GT4 using the SIGLOC footprint which seats the optic low for a true cowitness. Sig does not list the window size aside from "24mm objective" which doesn't help much since the objective lense is not round. Reports on the internet measure it to be roughly 0.81"x0.62" however the carry-friendly low mounting means the usable window is much smaller. Sig also does not list the diameter of the circle, only that the dot is available in 3 or 6 moa. I can say that the circle is considerably smaller in diameter than other circle+dot reticles. My best guess would be 12moa diameter.

The RMR-pattern OSight XE AMRS rode reasonable low on the BUL Armory TAC COMP thanks to BUL Armory's BAO optic mounting system. The XE AMRS had the largest window of the three with 0.91"x0.71" and options between 2moa or 6moa dot with or without a 32moa cirlce. We did not use the 6moa option.
The Test
Staying on Target: To see which reticle design works best once one is on target and wants to deliver repeat shot we timed attempting 5 shots on a 12" target from 20 yards.
Digested data (percentages reflect speed increase with winning reticle)
Staying on Target | Anna Quickest w/ | Graham Quickest w/ |
Canik Phantom on TriStar Arms APOC PRO | Dot (7%) | Dot (21%) |
Sig Rome-X on Sig P211 GT4 | Dot (12%) | Dot (5%) |
OSight XE AMRS on BUL Armory TAC COMP | Circle + Dot (3%) | Circle + Dot (2%) |
Speed and Transition: Dumping three quick shots on a full-size torso 7 yards away and then transitioning to a torso 21 yards away with a 5" bullseye on it.
Speed and Transition | Anna Quickest w/ | Graham Quickest w/ |
Canik Phantom on TriStar Arms APOC PRO | Circle + Dot (42%) | Circle + Dot (2%) |
Sig Rome-X on Sig P211 GT4 | Circle + Dot (55%) | Circle + Dot |
OSight XE AMRS on BUL Armory TAC COMP | Circle + Dot (7%) | Circle + Dot (15%) |
The test was not perfect, but results still showed clear differences from what we thought we liked and how we really performed. It is true that every time a drill or exercise is repeated it gets easier, and we used firearms in order from most-to-least difficult to perform with. To be absolute we'd need to repeat this same test on another day and use the firearms in the opposite order, but I think there are still some observations we can take from this:
Dot was generally better for both of us for remaining on target, or that while staying on a set target the reticle didn't make much of a difference. (Differences in speeds shown as percentages of the slower time).
Cirlce + Dot was absolutely better when needing to transition between two targets. Both users noted the circle made it easier to track movement through the glass and get roughly on target quicker.
While it's generally accepted that a larger window makes it easier to see what's going on, the large window of the OSight XE AMRS found us both doing better with circle + dot for both drills.
For a newer shooter like Anna who does not have as much previous experience transitioning between multiple targets the Circle + Dot provided a significant improvement.
On a High-Performance pistol like the BUL Armory TAC COMP the difference was not as significant as it is on pistols requiring a little more user effort.







Comments